Scottish National Budget: SNP and Greens manage to reach deal at the last minute
Through a last minute deal with the Greens the Scottish budget passed 67 for and 58 against.
On Thursday, Members of the Scottish Parliament debated Scotland’s annual national budget. That afternoon, it seemed quite unlikely that the Scottish Government would be able to accumulate enough support to see it through; however, a deal was reached only minutes before the debates began.
The Conservatives, Liberal Democrats and Labour ruled out their support for the budget proposals right from the beginning, mainly due to Scottish independence still being on the table for the SNP – something they would have liked to see change, albeit quite unrealistically.
Despite this considerable lack of support from the opposition parties, the Government was able to secure a deal with the Greens shortly before the first vote. This means that the Greens will support the government across all three stages of the process.
Finance Secretary Derek Mackay tweeted on Thursday that he was “pleased to have reached an agreement with the Scottish Green Party to deliver a Scottish budget that invests in health, education, our economy and supports local services.”
Scottish Greens co-convener Patrick Harvie tweeted that “Finally, after months of hard work and Green pressure for local tax reform and protection of local services, we have reached a budget agreement…this is what constructive politics looks like.”
The deal includes more core founding for councils and extra powers for them to levy local parking and tourist taxes. More specifically, it includes
- £90 million for the core local government settlement
- Cap on council tax rises increased to 4.79%
- A move to three-year local authority budgets
- Cross-party talks on replacing the council tax
Of course, not everyone was pleased with the results of the negotiations.
Scottish Lib Dem leader Willie Rennie stated on Thursday that the Scottish Government budget failed to deliver on issues of mental health, education and local government finance, highlighting a failure to scrap the council tax and a £50 million cut to social care.
The Labour Party, after effectively preventing Alex Rowley from carrying out any form of negotiation with the government, has criticised the deal, mainly citing cuts to local services as a point of contention.
Green Party MSP for West Scotland Ross Greer was critical of Richard Leonard and Labour’s stance on the issue, highlighting their unwillingness to negotiate and put forward any constructive proposals.
Scottish Conservative’s finance spokesman Murdo Fraser was also critical of the deal, dismissing it as a “triple-tax bombshell.” He added that “We will pay the highest income tax in the UK, council tax will go up, and now you might even get taxed hundreds of pounds a year for taking your car to work.”
Cosla, Scotland’s local government association, thanked the Greens for their support in the budget negotiations with the government.
The first stage of the vote consisted of a total of 125 votes, 67 for and 58 against, with one MSP abstaining.
The second stage will begin in mid-late February.
- Politics roundup: Theresa May’s latest defeat and post-Brexit trade agreements - February 15, 2019
- Nicola Sturgeon returns from North America visit after promoting Scottish trade and independence - February 13, 2019
- Nigel Farage’s new Brexit Party gets Electoral Commission approval - February 11, 2019
- Jeremy Corbyn’s Brexit demands cause Labour split - February 10, 2019
- Donald Tusk’s Brexit comments – misconstrued or rather telling? - February 8, 2019
- Why Guilt by Association is an Ineffective Political Strategy in Modern Politics - February 3, 2019
- Scottish National Budget: SNP and Greens manage to reach deal at the last minute - February 2, 2019